Study Highlights Housing Tradeoffs in Inclusionary Zoning Policies

Inclusionary Zoning
Published
Contact: Nicholas Julian
[email protected]
Director, Land Use
(202) 266-8309

A recent report, authored by the UCLA Lewis Center for Regional Policy Studies and published by the Terner Center at UC Berkeley, examines how inclusionary zoning rules impact housing production and affordability. The report notes that although inclusionary zoning can help increase housing for low-income families, the mandates also suppress overall housing production if taken too far.

The report primarily focuses on the city of Los Angeles’ Transit Oriented Communities (TOC) program. This program was implemented in 2017 with a goal of boosting housing production, including below-market rate units, near bus and train stations.

Inclusionary zoning (IZ) refers to local government ordinances that require a certain percentage of new residential construction to be sold or rented at below-market rates. According to the Terner Housing Policy Simulator, Los Angeles’ TOC program, with an IZ requirement of 11%, has likely boosted below-market-rate (BMR) homes with minimal negative consequences for overall housing production.

However, increasing the required percentage of BMR units under IZ policy could sharply reduce overall housing production with declining benefits for overall housing affordability.

This study finds that changing the IZ level entails significant tradeoffs between BMR and market-rate production. As the BMR requirement rises, there are diminishing returns to BMR production and accelerating losses to overall housing production. In simulating increases in IZ requirements, each percentage point increase in requirements between 1% and 16% is associated with a reduction of between 4,600 and 11,900 market-rate units.

Beyond a certain level, higher IZ requirements produce less BMR and less market-rate housing. A 20% IZ requirement, while producing 50,000 BMR units, would reduce market-rate production by over 200,000 units.

Additionally, the study found that even small increases in rent growth in the unrestricted rental market would be enough to negate the value of private IZ subsidies. For example, compared to a no-IZ scenario, additional rent growth of just 0.8% per year in the 16% scenario would negate the value of private subsidies from IZ. The author concludes that two critical aspects of IZ programs are providing development incentives when market-rate developers include BMR units and making program participation voluntary.

This analysis highlights the important tradeoffs policymakers should consider when setting the requirements of IZ policies.

To learn more about inclusionary zoning, visit NAHB's Land Use 101 toolkit.

Subscribe to NAHBNow

Log in or create account to subscribe to notifications of new posts.

Log in to subscribe

Latest from NAHBNow

Economics

Sep 17, 2025

Housing Starts Remain Soft Ahead of Fed Meeting

Overall housing starts decreased 8.5% in August to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 1.31 million units, according to a report from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and the U.S. Census Bureau.

PWB Week | Professional Women in Building Council

Sep 16, 2025

Tradeswomen Paving Their Own Way

NAHB spoke with Professional Women in Building (PWB) members Elyse Adams and Brittney Quinn about their career paths in the trades and how PWB has positively influenced their journeys.

View all

Latest Economic News

Economics

Sep 17, 2025

The Fed Cuts and Projects More Easing to Come

After a monetary policy pause that began at the start of 2025, the Federal Reserve’s monetary policy committee (FOMC) voted to reduce the short-term federal funds rate by 25 basis points at the conclusion of its September meeting. This move decreased the target federal funds rate to an upper rate of 4.25%.

Economics

Sep 17, 2025

Housing Starts Remain Soft Ahead of Fed Meeting

Challenging affordability conditions continue to act as headwinds for the housing industry, but the sector could see lower interest rates in the near future with the Federal Reserve expected to cut short-term interest rates this afternoon.

Economics

Sep 16, 2025

Builder Confidence Steady but Future Sales Expectations Hit Six-Month High

Builder sentiment levels remained unchanged in September but lower mortgage rates and expectations that the Federal Reserve will soon cut the federal funds rate led to higher future sale expectations in the coming months.