Supreme Court Rules Against EPA in Permitting Case Supported by NAHB

Legal
Published
Contact: Thomas Ward
[email protected]
VP, Legal Advocacy
(202) 266-8230

The U.S. Supreme Court yesterday handed down a decision in San Francisco v. EPA, a case concerning the Environmental Protection Agency’s duties to provide a path to compliance for certain clean water permits. NAHB filed an amicus brief in the case.

The case concerned “water quality standards” related to federal wastewater permits and how EPA must describe a permittee’s duties to meet those standards. In San Francisco’s permits, EPA said that the city had to meet the receiving waters’ — in this case, the Pacific Ocean — “water quality standard” without telling the city how that should be accomplished. San Francisco claimed this condition violated the Clean Water Act (CWA) and the Supreme Court agreed. 

NAHB filed an amicus brief in the case over the concern that if the court agreed with San Francisco’s argument, it could go too far and require EPA to include numeric discharge limits in CWA permits.

A large portion of NAHB members must comply with “construction general permits” (CGPs) due to their earthwork on site. CGPs contain “narrative” permit conditions, often referred to as “best management practices.” NAHB’s brief explained how narrative permit conditions comply with the CWA and cautioned the court not to eradicate them.

In deciding the case, the court focused on the words of the CWA that direct EPA to create limitations in permits to “meet” or “implement” water quality standards. It provided that simply telling permittees to comply with water quality standards does not explain how to “meet” or “implement” them. As a result, the court ruled in favor of San Francisco.

Moreover, the court went out of its way to ensure that the narrative requirements were not at issue in this case and that such requirements are allowed by the CWA. In fact, the court cited NAHB’s brief twice to make these points. 

Subscribe to NAHBNow

Log in or create account to subscribe to notifications of new posts.

Log in to subscribe

Latest from NAHBNow

PWB Week | Professional Women in Building Council

Sep 16, 2025

Tradeswomen Paving Their Own Way

NAHB spoke with Professional Women in Building (PWB) members Elyse Adams and Brittney Quinn about their career paths in the trades and how PWB has positively influenced their journeys.

Energy | Advocacy

Sep 16, 2025

Kansas City Builder Testifies Against Energy Code Mandates

The Home Builders Association of Greater Kansas City (KCHBA) called on Congress today to oppose energy code mandates that raise the cost of housing and do very little to increase energy efficiency for home owners.

View all

Latest Economic News

Economics

Sep 17, 2025

Housing Starts Remain Soft Ahead of Fed Meeting

Challenging affordability conditions continue to act as headwinds for the housing industry, but the sector could see lower interest rates in the near future with the Federal Reserve expected to cut short-term interest rates this afternoon.

Economics

Sep 16, 2025

Builder Confidence Steady but Future Sales Expectations Hit Six-Month High

Builder sentiment levels remained unchanged in September but lower mortgage rates and expectations that the Federal Reserve will soon cut the federal funds rate led to higher future sale expectations in the coming months.

Economics

Sep 15, 2025

Shelter Inflation Continued to Cool

Inflation accelerated to a seven month high in August as tariff-related costs continued to pass through to consumers, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ (BLS) latest report. Core goods prices, which exclude volatile food and energy, rose by 1.5% in August, the fastest annual pace since May 2023.