NAHB Wins Legal Decision on Eviction Moratorium Case
On March 10, NAHB won a key legal decision when the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio ruled that by issuing a nationwide eviction moratorium the Centers for Disease and Control Prevention (CDC) exceeded the authority Congress had granted it.
NAHB had filed suit in the district court along with Monarch Investment Management Group and Skyworks, Ltd. regarding what we asserted was the lack of authority of the CDC to issue an eviction moratorium. NAHB was also assisted by the Sterling Group, who provided an affidavit illustrating the harm caused by this moratorium.
The ruling in the case, entitled Skyworks, Ltd., et al. v. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, et al., sets a great precedent against government overreach.
The court addressed two legal questions: 1) did Congress provide the CDC with the authority to issue a nationwide eviction moratorium in section 361 of the Public Health Services Act, and 2) did Congress later ratify the CDC’s moratorium in the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021?
With respect to the first question, the court found the statute was clear.
“Because the Court determines that the statute is unambiguous and, by issuing a nationwide eviction moratorium, CDC exceeded the authority Congress gave it in Section 361, the Court holds that action unlawful and sets it aside, as the APA [Administrative Procedures Act] requires,” the court ruling stated.
On the second question, the judge explained that all Congress did was extend the moratorium, but never reviewed CDC’s authority to issue the order and certainly never ratified it.
The government is now in a very difficult position because the court made clear that it was setting aside the eviction moratorium order under the APA.
At this point, it is unclear whether the federal government will seek to limit the decision only to the plaintiffs involved, or to Ohio.
For more information, contact Tom Ward or Devala Janardan.
Latest from NAHBNow
Jul 03, 2025
Consumer Confidence Retreats in JuneAfter a strong rebound in May, consumer confidence resumed its downward trend in June. Consumers remain concerned about the economy and labor market amid ongoing uncertainty, especially around tariffs.
Jul 02, 2025
5 Proven Strategies Smart Builders Use to Grow in Any MarketSound Capital has worked with builders across market cycles for over 20 years. They have seen who thrived when others pulled back, and they've studied the strategies they used to scale while competitors were sidelined. Here are five things they all had in common.
Latest Economic News
Jul 03, 2025
Solid Job Growth in JuneThe U.S. labor market continued to show resilience in June, with steady job gains led by state/local government and health care sectors.
Jul 02, 2025
Two or More Story Home Starts Rebound in 2024Over half of new single-family homes built in 2024 were two or more stories, according the recent release of the Census Bureau’s Survey of Construction (SOC). After declining in 2023, the share of homes started with two or more stories increased again in 2024, continuing the upward trend in place since 2020.
Jul 01, 2025
May Private Residential Construction Spending DipsPrivate residential construction spending fell by 0.5% in May, marking the fifth straight month of decreases. This drop was primarily driven by reduced spending on single-family construction. Compared to a year ago, total spending was down 6.7%, as the housing sector continues to navigate the economic uncertainty stemming from ongoing tariff concerns and elevated mortgage rates.