State Supreme Court Denies NIMBY Challenge to Zoning Reform

Legal
Published

The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court last week upheld the constitutionality of the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority (MBTA) Communities Act, which mandated zoning changes across the state. Significantly, it was an enforcement action from the state’s attorney general against a town that led to the decision.

The MBTA Communities Act mandates that cities and towns served by MBTA adopt zoning laws allowing for at least one district of multifamily housing “as of right” within a half mile of transit facilities. Designed to increase housing stock and promote transit-oriented development, the act faced resistance when NIMBYs in the Town of Milton rejected a proposed zoning bylaw aimed at meeting these requirements. The attorney general intervened with an enforcement lawsuit against the town, leading to a decisive court ruling.

Why This Victory Matters

Much like the rest of the country, Massachusetts faces a growing demand for homes. But outdated and unnecessarily restrictive zoning laws often hinder progress. The MBTA Communities Act hits this problem head-on by mandating municipalities allow higher-density housing near transit hubs. This approach not only increases housing supply but also fosters walkable, sustainable neighborhoods.

The act also includes a provision calling for the state’s attorney general to enforce its rules through legal actions against municipalities. 

In supporting this case, the Home Builders and Remodelers Association of Massachusetts, supported by NAHB’s Legal Action Fund, highlighted the broader implications of zoning reform. Housing shortages affect everyone — from young families seeking starter homes to seniors in need of accessible options. 

3 Key Takeaways from the Court’s Decision

The Supreme Judicial Court’s ruling emphasizes:

  1. Affirmation of constitutionality: The court upheld the MBTA Communities Act, confirming its legal foundation.
  2. Attorney general’s enforcement powers: The attorney general is empowered to ensure municipal compliance.
  3. Guideline revisions required: The court required procedural corrections to the guidelines but upheld the act’s validity.

What This Means for the Housing Industry

This decision creates opportunities to build much-needed homes. Multifamily developments near transit hubs alleviate shortages, boost local economies, and reduce environmental impacts. For home builders, this represents a chance to meet pressing housing needs while supporting sustainable growth.

NAHB stands committed to policies that enable responsible development. This case sets a precedent, showing that zoning reform is a statewide priority essential for addressing housing challenges.

Looking Ahead

While this ruling is a major victory, the work continues. Municipalities in Massachusetts must align with the MBTA Communities Act, and guidelines must be revised to meet procedural standards. 

The case also serves a reminder that passing legislation at the state level does not solve the problem. NIMBYs will always try to find a way to persuade municipalities to not comply. Any efforts at zoning reform must include enforcement mechanisms.

NAHB remains ready to assist in these efforts, advocating for housing solutions that benefit all residents.

The outcome of this case could have far-reaching effects on housing affordability and zoning regulations nationwide. NAHB’s support in this case was provided through the Legal Action Fund at nahb.org/legalfund. Applications for the next cycle of support are due by Feb. 5.

Subscribe to NAHBNow

Log in or create account to subscribe to notifications of new posts.

Log in to subscribe

Latest from NAHBNow

Student Chapters | Workforce Development

Jul 25, 2025

NAHB's Student Chapters Helped Give Her Confidence to Pivot Careers

Zhetique Gunn's early exposure to building and problem-solving has led to national recognition and a city-level impact as an urban planner in Washington, D.C.

Jul 24, 2025

Federal Court Upholds New York State Gas Ban

The federal court for the Northern District of New York on July 23 upheld New York state’s “gas ban” legislation. New York’s legislation is the first statewide law that restricts natural gas use in new buildings, effectively banning gas stoves and other fossil fuel appliances in most new construction starting in 2026.

View all

Latest Economic News

Economics

Jul 25, 2025

Market Share of 5,000+ Square Foot New Homes Started Declines in 2024

In 2024, there were 24,000 homes that exceeded 5,000 square feet, equating to a 2.3% market share of all new homes started. Both the number and market share for 5,000+ square foot homes experienced declines from 2023, according to the annual data from the Census Bureau’s Survey of Construction (SOC).

Economics

Jul 24, 2025

New Home Sales Hold Steady at a Relatively Tepid Level

Challenging affordability conditions, elevated interest rates and economic uncertainty continue to act as headwinds on the housing sector as many potential buyers continue to stay on the sidelines.

Economics

Jul 23, 2025

Existing Home Sales Retreat to 9-Month Low

Existing home sales fell to 9-month low in June as home prices hit another monthly record high, according to the National Association of Realtors (NAR). Sluggish pace of sales suggest that higher mortgage rates and elevated home prices are continuing to sideline buyers, despite improved inventory conditions.