Harvard Research Examines State and Local Programs Promoting Middle-Income Housing
The Harvard University Joint Center for Housing Studies (JCHS) recently released a white paper, “Subsidizing the Middle: Policies, Tradeoffs, and Costs of Addressing Middle-Income Affordability Challenges,” that examines 11 state and local programs designed to address middle-income housing needs amid the housing affordability crisis.
The programs that the JCHS researchers analyze target middle-income rental households — which constitute 14.4 million renters, or one-third of all renters nationally, who earn between 60 to 120% of area median income (AMI) — through direct or indirect public subsidies.
“Numerous state and local middle-income housing programs have been created in recent years with the explicit intent to address the affordability challenges of households in the workforce,” the paper notes. “These programs suggest that working adults should be able to afford to live in the communities where they work.”
State programs examined include:
- Florida: Missing Middle Property Tax Exemption
- Georgia: Rural Workforce Housing Initiative
- Michigan: Missing Middle Housing Program
- Colorado: Middle-Income Housing Authority
- Rhode Island: Middle Income Loan Program
- California: CSCDA Workforce Housing Program
- Minnesota: Workforce Housing Development Program
- Massachusetts: Workforce Housing Initiative
- Kansas: Moderate Income Housing Program
Local programs examined include:
- Philadelphia: Workforce Housing Credit Enhancement
- Breckenridge, Colo.: Workforce Housing Five-Year Blueprint
Although the programs differ in terms of funding, activities and requirements, the researchers identified several key themes, including the recent focus on this segment of housing, the use of AMI as a threshold to determine eligibility, and geographic diversity of these programs.
Researchers also found that these middle-income housing programs are primarily focused on “expanding the supply of housing affordable to middle-income households through new development, though many projects also fund rehabilitation, adaptive reuse, or acquisition and conversion.”
Most programs offer favorable or forgivable construction financing to developers of middle-income housing, the paper adds, as well as grant funding directly to developers. Some programs provide a cap on per-unit funding, which may depend on the type of activity funded and/or subsidy provided.
Researchers note that many of these programs are relatively new, so it’s difficult to determine their full impact. The research also takes a comparative look at middle- vs. low-income renters — based on factors such as housing affordability challenges, employment status, geography and demographic details, and identifies the benefits and concerns surrounding middle-income housing programs — with concerns that these programs may be overshadowing the needs for the nation’s most cost-burdened renters.
In addition to these types of housing programs, JCHS researchers propose that states and localities look toward additional solutions outside of subsidies to help increase housing supply — solutions that underline key points from NAHB’s 10-point plan.
“Liberalizing local zoning ordinances, particularly in areas that allow only single-family homes, can encourage a broader range of housing types like small multifamily buildings, ADUs, or manufactured homes, and can make it easier to increase the overall stock,” the paper states. “Expedited permit processes, relief from some environmental or community review requirements, reduced parking mandates, or density bonuses for projects that hit a specified affordability level could also encourage development that benefits middle-income renters.”
Visit jchs.harvard.edu to view the full report.
Latest from NAHBNow
Jun 16, 2025
Permit Activity Declines for Fourth Consecutive MonthHousing permits continued a downhill trend for the fourth month in a row, pointing to a broader residential construction slowdown for 2025. Single-family permits were down in three out of four regions, while multifamily permits were up in three out of four regions. See the 10 largest markets for single-family and multifamily activity.
Jun 13, 2025
Podcast: Addressing the Labor Shortage through Advocacy and Key CollaborationsOn the latest episode of NAHB’s podcast, Housing Developments, CEO Jim Tobin and COO Paul Lopez are joined by SkillsUSA Executive Director Chelle Travis to discuss a new collaboration with NAHB’s Professional Women in Building (PWB) Council to bridge the workforce gap in construction.
Latest Economic News
Jun 16, 2025
Permit Activity Weakens in April 2025Housing permits continued a downhill trend for the fourth month in a row, pointing to a broader residential construction slowdown for 2025. Over the first four months of 2025, the total number of single-family permits issued year-to-date (YTD) nationwide reached 320,259.
Jun 13, 2025
Household Real Estate Asset Value Falls to Start the YearThe market value of household real estate assets fell from $48.1 trillion to $47.9 trillion in the first quarter of 2025, according to the most recent release of U.S. Federal Reserve Z.1 Financial Accounts. The value of household real estate assets declined for three consecutive quarters after peaking at $48.8 trillion in the second quarter of 2024 but remains 2.1% higher over the year.
Jun 12, 2025
Producer Prices Rise in May: New Construction Input AnalysisPrices for inputs to new residential construction—excluding capital investment, labor, and imports—rose 0.2% in May, following a (revised) decrease of 0.2% in April. These figures are taken from the most recent Producer Price Index (PPI) report published by U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.