NAHB Supports Challenge to HUD’s Rule-Making Authority

Legal
Published
Contact: Thomas Ward
[email protected]
VP, Legal Advocacy
(202) 266-8230

NAHB recently filed an amicus brief in National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies v. Department of Housing and Urban Development at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia. The case involves a challenge by the insurance industry to HUD’s Disparate Impact Rule. The rule has a long history dating back to the Obama administration.

In 2013, HUD published a rule formalizing a “burden-shifting” test for determining whether a housing practice being challenged in court has an unjustified discriminatory effect.

Under the test, the plaintiff must first prove a challenged practice caused or predictably will cause a discriminatory effect. If the plaintiff meets its burden of proof, then the defendant must prove the challenged practice is necessary to achieve one or more substantial, legitimate, nondiscriminatory interests. If the defendant meets this burden, then the plaintiff may still prevail upon proving that the substantial, legitimate, nondiscriminatory interests supporting the challenged practice could be served by another practice that has a less discriminatory effect.

The current version of the rule, promulgated early in the Biden administration, basically recodifies the 2013 rule.

On May 8, NAHB filed an amicus brief in the case challenging HUD’s authority to issue the rule. NAHB explained that the rule establishes judicial procedures and evidentiary standards that are usually created by courts.

Furthermore, NAHB argued that HUD exceeded its authority because Congress did not provide it with a clear statement allowing it to develop rules for the judiciary. Because the Constitution allows the executive branch to choose judges, if it can also set the rules for how those judges must try cases, too much power is concentrated in one branch of government.

Finally, one of the reasons HUD provided for developing the rule was that the federal Courts of Appeals were not in agreement on procedures/standards to be used when trying disparate impact cases. NAHB pointed out that when Courts of Appeals disagree, it is the Supreme Court that resolves the split, not federal agencies.

Briefing in this case should be complete by the end of July, and oral argument is expected before the end of the year.

Subscribe to NAHBNow

Log in or create account to subscribe to notifications of new posts.

Log in to subscribe

Latest from NAHBNow

IBS | Design
Nov 16, 2026
Modern-Desert Landscape Takes Shape at IBS 2027 Exhibit Home

One of the most striking elements of the IBS 2027 exhibit home is the landscape design, which plays a defining role in connecting the home to its surrounding environment.

Construction Costs | Material Costs
Nov 16, 2026
Building Material Prices 10% Higher than a Year Ago

The price index for goods used in new residential construction (including energy) was unchanged in October compared to September, but was up 9.8% from October 2025, according to the Producer Price Index inflation report.

View all

Latest Economic News

Economics
Nov 17, 2026
Custom Home Building Share Rises in 2025

Custom homes accounted for 19.6 % of all single-family homes started in 2025 up from the 17.5 % in 2024. The custom home market consists of contractor-built and owner-built houses—homes built one at a time for owner occupancy on the owner’s land, with either the owner or a builder acting as a general contractor.

Economics
Nov 17, 2026
Builder Sentiment Continues to Fall on Affordability Concerns

Builder confidence has dropped to a 14-year low, dragged down by high mortgage rates, ongoing inflation pressure, elevated energy and material costs, rising labor shortages and hesitant buyers.

Economics
Nov 16, 2026
Single-Family Permitting Weakens While Multifamily Activity Remains Stronger

Residential permitting activity continued to show divergent trends across the single-family and multifamily sectors through September 2026. Single-family permitting remained under pressure, with year-to-date activity declining from a year earlier amid ongoing housing affordability challenges and elevated construction costs.