ADA Litigation Mill Case Heard at the U.S. Supreme Court

Legal
Published
Contact: Jeff Augello
[email protected]
AVP, Association Counsel
(202) 266-8490

The U.S. Supreme Court on Oct. 3 heard oral arguments in Acheson Hotels LLC v. Laufer, a case centering on whether “testers” have Article III standing to leverage the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and sue hotels for failing to provide disability accessibility information on their website.

Deborah Laufer, a self-described “tester,” is responsible for filing upwards of 600 boilerplate lawsuits targeting small hotels that fail to detail the accessibility features offered at their place of lodging through their websites. Laufer, who lives in Florida, never physically visits the hotels she sues. Acheson’s Coast Village Inn & Cottages, her latest target, is located in Wells, Maine. Despite never having visited the Coast Village Inn & Cottages, Laufer claims she suffered an injury of “frustration” and “humiliation” when she encountered Acheson’s website and its lack of accessibility information.

Laufer’s well-oiled litigation machine hit a bump soon after the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case. First, the U.S. Solicitor’s Office filed an amicus brief arguing the ADA and its implementing regulations do not create a free-standing informational right to accessibility information and that Laufer lacks standing. (NAHB also filed an amicus brief against Laufer, arguing her complaint should be dismissed for lack of standing.) After one of Laufer’s attorneys had his legal license suspended due to ethics violations, Laufer voluntarily dismissed her case against Acheson and filed a “suggestion of mootness.” The Supreme Court denied her request for dismissal on mootness.

It was not clear following the oral arguments whether the Supreme Court will actually rule on the standing of ADA testers. Several justices noted that the case has been dismissed by Laufer, the website at issue is now compliant with the ADA, and the original defendant has sold the hotel.

Justice Elena Kagan remarked that the case is “dead, dead, dead in all the ways that something can be dead” and using this case “as the vehicle for deciding an important issue … just doesn’t seem like something that a court should — should be anxious to do.”

Several other justices were not so keen to simply drop the case. Chief Justice John Roberts expressed concern over Laufer’s litigation tactic of mooting the case “to manipulate the jurisdiction of the court, after the Court’s granted cert” (cert means if four justices agree to hear a case, then the court will hear the case).

In a sentiment shared by Acheson and thousands of small businesses around the country targeted by extortionate ADA “testers,” mooting the case would be “blessing the legal strategy of filing large numbers of lawsuits … and abandoning them at the last minute” so that another lawsuit can be filed against the same small business the very next day.

Subscribe to NAHBNow

Log in or create account to subscribe to notifications of new posts.

Log in to subscribe

Latest from NAHBNow

Resiliency | Codes and Standards

Sep 03, 2025

How Building Codes Can – and Can’t – Help in Floods

Could enhanced building codes help save lives and property in flood-prone areas? Perhaps. But it is important to note there are already enhanced building codes required in flood zones.

Associate Members Committee | Membership

Sep 02, 2025

NAHB Kicks Off Associate Member Appreciation Month 2025

NAHB is celebrating the successes and contributions of its roughly 70,000 Associate members during September for Associate Member Appreciation Month, including a message from NAHB Chairman Buddy Hughes.

View all

Latest Economic News

Economics

Sep 03, 2025

Open Construction Jobs Rise in July

The count of open, unfilled positions in the construction industry increased in July, per the June Bureau of Labor Statistics Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) as the national labor market cooled.

Economics

Sep 03, 2025

House Price Appreciation by State and Metro Area: Second Quarter 2025

House price growth continued to slow in the second quarter of 2025, as the housing market faces mounting pressure from high mortgage rates, elevated inventory, and persistent economic uncertainty.

Economics

Sep 02, 2025

June Private Residential Construction Spending Edges Higher

Private residential construction spending inched up 0.1% in June, registering the first monthly gain after six consecutive declines.