NAHB, Other Groups Urge Supreme Court to Take New York Rent Control Case
NAHB and three other organizations are calling on the Supreme Court to consider whether a New York rent control law acts as a regulatory taking because the property owners have been deprived of all meaningful rights with respect to their property, including:
- The right to exclude others from the property;
- The right to occupy, possess or use the property; and
- The right to freely dispose of the property.
In addition, the New York Rent Guidelines Board has precluded stabilized property owners from raising rents at a rate consistent with the board’s own estimate of the increased costs of ownership and maintenance. Not surprisingly, the value of rent stabilized properties are now far below their market-based peers.
And despite the rent stabilization law’s (“RSL”) imposition of what amounts to a privately funded and randomly assigned housing subsidy, the law has failed to achieve any of the goals for which it was ostensibly created: It does not increase vacancy rates, it does not increase the supply of affordable housing, it does not target those in greater financial need, and it does not promote diversity in the city.
Furthermore, the New York legislature enacted the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019 (HSTPA), which eliminates any previous opportunities for property owners to reset their units to market rate.
The HSTPA prevents owners from substantially recovering investments in individual apartment improvements or major capital improvements, forcing owners to choose between bearing repair costs themselves without any ability to recover those costs through increased rent or allowing buildings to deteriorate over time.
The HSTPA further restricts the ability of owners to convert properties to condominiums or cooperatives. Under the new law, they must have 51% of all tenants agree to purchase contracts for their units — a requirement that effectively precludes the ability to convert altogether.
As a result of these draconian actions, NAHB, along with the National Apartment Association, the National Association of Realtors and the Mortgage Bankers Association, have filed a friend-of-the-court brief in support of New York property owners regarding two rent stabilization cases that are currently pending.
The Supreme Court has not indicated yet whether it will address the New York rent control laws, but NAHB and our allies are making a forceful case that this is a takings claim because New York’s rent control scheme does not allow property owners the fundamental right to possess and dispose of their own property.
The due process claim is that the law does not accomplish its goals — it does not increase vacancy rates or the supply of affordable housing. And it does not help those in financial need or increase diversity.
As these are constitutional claims, NAHB believes this is truly a national case.
Latest from NAHBNow
Jul 25, 2025
NAHB's Student Chapters Helped Give Her Confidence to Pivot CareersZhetique Gunn's early exposure to building and problem-solving has led to national recognition and a city-level impact as an urban planner in Washington, D.C.
Jul 24, 2025
Federal Court Upholds New York State Gas BanThe federal court for the Northern District of New York on July 23 upheld New York state’s “gas ban” legislation. New York’s legislation is the first statewide law that restricts natural gas use in new buildings, effectively banning gas stoves and other fossil fuel appliances in most new construction starting in 2026.
Latest Economic News
Jul 25, 2025
Market Share of 5,000+ Square Foot New Homes Started Declines in 2024In 2024, there were 24,000 homes that exceeded 5,000 square feet, equating to a 2.3% market share of all new homes started. Both the number and market share for 5,000+ square foot homes experienced declines from 2023, according to the annual data from the Census Bureau’s Survey of Construction (SOC).
Jul 24, 2025
New Home Sales Hold Steady at a Relatively Tepid LevelChallenging affordability conditions, elevated interest rates and economic uncertainty continue to act as headwinds on the housing sector as many potential buyers continue to stay on the sidelines.
Jul 23, 2025
Existing Home Sales Retreat to 9-Month LowExisting home sales fell to 9-month low in June as home prices hit another monthly record high, according to the National Association of Realtors (NAR). Sluggish pace of sales suggest that higher mortgage rates and elevated home prices are continuing to sideline buyers, despite improved inventory conditions.