NAHB Joint Efforts Successful in Minnesota Takings Case

Legal
Published
Contact: Thomas Ward
[email protected]
VP, Legal Advocacy
(202) 266-8230

In a key win for NAHB and private property owners, the Supreme Court on May 25 handed down a unanimous decision delivering a victory to a landowner in a takings case out of Hennepin County, Minn. The landowner, 94-year-old Geraldine Tyler, owned a condominium that accumulated approximately $2,300 in unpaid real estate taxes and $13,000 in interest and penalties. The county sold Ms. Tyler’s property for $40,000, which satisfied her $15,000 tax debt. But under Minnesota law, the county kept the $25,000 in excess proceeds as a windfall.

Ms. Tyler sued Hennepin County, alleging the seizure of the excess proceeds from the sale of her house constituted a violation of the Fifth Amendment’s takings clause and a violation of the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition on excessive fines. At the trial court level, the case was dismissed for failure to state a claim. The Eighth Circuit affirmed.

Upon review, the Supreme Court found that Ms. Tyler’s lawsuit did in fact state a plausible claim. The county keeping the excess proceeds constituted a taking.

Seizing upon points raised in NAHB’s joint amicus brief, the Supreme Court noted that while state law is an important source of property rights, it cannot be used to circumvent traditional property interests. The Supreme Court also recognized the brief’s argument that since the Magna Carta, English and American common law has required governments to return any surplus from property taken to pay tax debts.

Again agreeing with the brief, the Supreme Court acknowledged the inconsistency of Minnesota law on the issue of excess proceeds. Banks in Minnesota are required by state law to return excess proceeds from a foreclosure sale to the home owner.

Minnesota law also protects the taxpayer’s right to surplus when collecting past due taxes on income or personal property. Yet, in the context of real estate taxes, Minnesota was pocketing the excess in real estate tax sales. This inconsistency was glaring to the unanimous Supreme Court.

Lastly, the Supreme Court rejected Hennepin County’s argument that Ms. Tyler had abandoned her property by failing to pay taxes, and therefore, had no right to the excess proceeds. The Supreme Court succinctly stated the county cannot “frame... [the failure to pay taxes] …as abandonment to avoid the demands of the Takings Clause.”

This win is not only important to Ms. Tyler but to property owners nationwide. No longer can localities seize windfalls on the excess proceeds from tax sales. This case also makes clear that states cannot circumvent traditional property rights via state law.

Subscribe to NAHBNow

Log in or create account to subscribe to notifications of new posts.

Log in to subscribe

Latest from NAHBNow

Advocacy
Nov 17, 2026
Midterm Election Recap: Access Members-Only Webinar

On Nov. 9, NAHB hosted a members-only webinar, “What the Midterm Elections Mean for Housing,” to delve into the results of the midterm elections, key ballot measures and what to expect in the new Congress. NAHB members and HBA staff can access a replay of the webinar on nahb.org.

Economics
Nov 17, 2026
Builder Sentiment Continues to Fall on Affordability Concerns

Builder confidence in the market for newly built single-family homes fell four points to 25 in November, according to the NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index (HMI) released today. The reading was the lowest since April 2012.

View all

Latest Economic News

Economics
Nov 17, 2026
Custom Home Building Share Rises in 2025

Custom homes accounted for 19.6 % of all single-family homes started in 2025 up from the 17.5 % in 2024. The custom home market consists of contractor-built and owner-built houses—homes built one at a time for owner occupancy on the owner’s land, with either the owner or a builder acting as a general contractor.

Economics
Nov 17, 2026
Builder Sentiment Continues to Fall on Affordability Concerns

Builder confidence has dropped to a 14-year low, dragged down by high mortgage rates, ongoing inflation pressure, elevated energy and material costs, rising labor shortages and hesitant buyers.

Economics
Nov 16, 2026
Single-Family Permitting Weakens While Multifamily Activity Remains Stronger

Residential permitting activity continued to show divergent trends across the single-family and multifamily sectors through September 2026. Single-family permitting remained under pressure, with year-to-date activity declining from a year earlier amid ongoing housing affordability challenges and elevated construction costs.