NAHB-Supported Landlords Lose Rent Control Court Decision in New York

Legal
Published
Contact: Thomas Ward
[email protected]
VP, Legal Advocacy
(202) 266-8230

The Second Circuit Court of Appeals on Feb. 6 handed down a loss to rent control opponents in New York City. A group of landlords, supported by NAHB, brought suit alleging the city’s rent stabilization law is an unconstitutional taking under the Fifth Amendment both “on its face” and “as applied.” Neither of these arguments were successful.

“Facial” challenges are some of the most difficult to prove because the litigant must show there is no situation in which the rent stabilization law would be constitutional. The appellate court looked to the “well settled case law” affording municipalities great discretion in handling landlord-tenant relationships and found that the landlords failed to allege that rent control was unconstitutional in all circumstances.

Although “as applied” challenges are easier to prove, the court of appeals failed to find a physical invasion of the landlords’ property, a requirement necessary to demonstrate a taking. Despite the landlords’ novel arguments to the contrary, the court was not persuaded and again looked to historical case law upholding rent control.

The landlords will look to the U.S. Supreme Court for relief, as its current composition is ripe for a potential change in the jurisprudence.

Subscribe to NAHBNow

Log in or create account to subscribe to notifications of new posts.

Log in to subscribe

Latest from NAHBNow

Awards

Oct 03, 2025

NAHB Awards Deadline Extended to Oct. 20

Interested applicants for NAHB’s prestigious award programs now have additional time to submit top projects and individuals for consideration. Don't miss your chance - apply by Monday, Oct. 20.

Sponsored Content

Oct 03, 2025

Fast Money, Fewer Headaches

Every week lost to underwriting is a week you’re not building, selling, or scaling. Delays push projects out of prime seasons, tighten cash flow, and leave crews idle. And when banks already move at their own pace, builders who aren’t prepared can get stuck at the back of the line.

View all

Latest Economic News

Economics

Oct 03, 2025

Supply-Side Cost Pressures Drove Housing as Inflation Leader in 2024

Though the rate of inflation peaked in June 2022, consumer prices continued to increase throughout 2023 and 2024 as inflation drove further price growth, according to 2024 CPI review from the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Economics

Oct 02, 2025

Square Foot Prices Moderate in 2024

Median square foot prices for new single-family detached (SFD) homes started in 2024 grew modestly, according to NAHB’s analysis of the latest Survey of Construction (SOC) data. For custom, or contractor-built, homes, the median price was $166 per square foot of floor space, up slightly from $162 in 2023.

Economics

Oct 02, 2025

17% of NAHB Builders Built Age-Restricted Housing in 2024

Only 17% of NAHB builder members build age-restricted housing for people age 55 or older, according to 2024 Member Census. This is up two percentage points from the previous year. However, this share has remained within a narrow band (15%-17%) since the question was added to the member census in 2009.