How the Supreme Court Decision to Rein in EPA Authority Could Affect Builders

Legal
Published

The Supreme Court last week issued a decision that is generally positive toward NAHB’s interests when it voted 6-3 to restrict the ability of the Environmental Protection Agency to regulate carbon emissions.

In the case of West Virginia et al v. EPA et al, the high court ruled that the EPA exceeded the authority of the Clean Air Act when it promulgated the Clean Power Plan (CPP) during the Obama administration. The decision’s main relevance for NAHB is its discussion of an administrative law principle, the “major questions doctrine.”

The major questions doctrine holds that unless Congress has clearly stated its intent for a federal agency to exercise its authority to regulate an issue, courts must reject the agency’s approach. In this case, the Supreme Court said the EPA asserted “highly consequential power beyond what Congress could reasonably be understood to have granted.”

The major questions doctrine is helpful to NAHB because it sets a higher bar for courts when faced with agencies using existing statutory authorities for novel regulatory approaches.

With regard to the CPP rule itself, the original rule had never gone into effect, and most of the deadlines and goals were met through market forces. In its original form, the CPP contained provisions that would have incentivized the adoption of stringent energy efficiency building codes for new construction.

While it was unlikely that the Biden administration would bring back the original CPP, the Supreme Court’s ruling cements that reality, and EPA will be unable to set a section 111(d) rule that impacts NAHB members through demand-side efficiency requirements.

The Supreme Court’s application and discussion of the major questions doctrine will be helpful to NAHB members in addressing agency attempts to create new regulatory programs that depart significantly from statute.

Subscribe to NAHBNow

Log in or create account to subscribe to notifications of new posts.

Log in to subscribe

Latest from NAHBNow

Disaster Response

Sep 12, 2025

Builders’ Guide to Keeping Job Sites and Communities Prepared

September is National Preparedness Month, an annual federal initiative to raise awareness and equip individuals, businesses and communities with the tools they need to prepare for disasters.

IBS | Awards

Sep 11, 2025

2026 Best of IBS Awards Open

The NAHB International Builders’ Show® (IBS) recognizes the outstanding building products and services with the Best of IBS Awards. Apply by Nov. 21, 2025, to showcase your products.

View all

Latest Economic News

Economics

Sep 12, 2025

Household Real Estate Asset Values Reach New High

The market value of household real estate assets rose to $49.3 trillion in the second quarter of 2025, according to the most recent release of U.S. Federal Reserve Z.1 Financial Accounts. The value rose by 2.7% from the first quarter and is 1.1% higher than a year ago. This measure of market value estimates the value of all owner-occupied real estate nationwide.

Economics

Sep 11, 2025

Parking Trends in Newly Completed Single-Family Homes, 2024

In 2024, 65% of newly completed single-family homes featured two-car garages, according to NAHB’s analysis of the Census’s Survey of Construction data. The share of new homes with three or more car garages stood at 15%, continuing a downward trend from its peak of 24% in 2015 and decreasing 2 percentage points from 2023.

Economics

Sep 10, 2025

Year-over-Year Building Material Price Growth Advances

Price growth for residential building materials rose for the fourth straight month in August, reaching its highest level since January 2023. Across domestic inputs goods and services into residential construction, service prices decreased in August while goods prices slightly advanced.