Supreme Court Opinion Allows CFPB to Keep Operating; President Can Remove the Director
In a ruling that will avoid disruptions to the nation’s mortgage and lending markets, the Supreme Court ruled today that the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) can continue operating but the president has the authority to remove the director “at will.”
In a decision written by Chief Justice John Roberts, the court held that the CFPB’s structure – which includes a single director that can only be removed for cause by the president – is unconstitutional. However, the court also held that the remedy to this constitutional issue is to sever the for-cause provision from the statute. Thus, the CFPB remains intact and the director can be removed at will by the president.
The ruling stated: “…[T]here are compelling reasons not to extend [prior] precedents to the novel context of an independent agency led by a single Director. Such an agency lacks a foundation in historical practice and clashes with constitutional structure by concentrating power in a unilateral actor insulated from Presidential control. We therefore hold that the structure of the CFPB violates the separation of powers. We go on to hold that the CFPB Director’s removal protection is severable from the other statutory provisions bearing on the CFPB’s authority. The agency may therefore continue to operate, but its Director, in light of our decision, must be removable by the President at will.”
NAHB joined an amicus brief with the Mortgage Bankers Association and National Association of Realtors that contended if the Supreme Court found CFPB’s structure unconstitutional, it should sever the “for-cause” provision in order to avoid massive disruption in the mortgage and lending markets that would result if CFPB were disbanded.
The Supreme Court’s ruling today prevents this disruption by preserving the agency while addressing the unconstitutional provision.
A very similar case was brought against the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) in the Fifth Circuit. Last year, that court held, in an en banc (a case heard before all the judges) opinion, that the FHFA structure was likewise unconstitutional and could be remedied similarly by severing the for-cause provision from the statute. Both parties in this case (Collins v. Mnuchin) sought the Supreme Court’s review, and those petitions are still pending.
For more information, email [email protected].
Latest from NAHBNow
Sep 24, 2025
2026 Remodeled Show Home Goes Light on Demolition, Heavy on EfficiencyEven though The New American Remodel 2026 will not undergo major structural changes, the strategic design updates and modern product integrations will transform the property from a dated, energy-guzzling residence into a sustainable, high-performance gem.
Sep 24, 2025
New Home Sales Post Unexpected Large Gain in AugustSales of newly built single-family homes jumped 20.5% higher in August, to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 800,000 from an upwardly revised reading in July, according to newly released data from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and the U.S. Census Bureau. The pace of new home sales is up 15.4% from a year earlier. The three-month moving average of new home sales was 713,000, an increase from the 656,000 in July. New home sales remain down 1.4% on a year-to-date basis.
Latest Economic News
Sep 24, 2025
New Home Sales Post Unexpected Large Gain in AugustA modest drop in mortgage rates led to a surprisingly large jump in new home sales in August, though the figure may be revised downward in the coming month.
Sep 24, 2025
Single-Family Construction Loan Volume Falls BackThe NAHB Land Acquisition, Development and Construction (AD&C) loan survey in the second quarter reported tightening credit conditions for builders. Consequently, FDIC data reporting the outstanding volume of 1-4 family construction loans fell in the second quarter.
Sep 23, 2025
Beyond the Official Unemployment Rate: A Deep Dive into U.S. UnemploymentIn August, the official, or standardly referenced, unemployment rate rose slightly to 4.3%, up from 4.2% in July. This marks the highest level in nearly four years, though it remains historically low.