What the 2026 Elections Could Mean for the Courts
The 2026 midterm elections did not immediately change the composition of the nation’s courts. But they may have changed something nearly as important: who controls the process for filling federal judicial vacancies, including any vacancy on the U.S. Supreme Court.
Democrats will control the Senate when the new Congress convenes in January. That matters because, although the president nominates federal judges, the Constitution gives the Senate the power to confirm them. For the remaining two years of President Trump’s term, that could substantially constrain the administration’s ability to reshape the federal judiciary.
Expect a Lame-Duck Push on Judges
The first effect may come before the new Congress even takes office.
Republicans still control the Senate during the lame-duck period, giving them a relatively short window to move pending Trump judicial nominees through the confirmation process. Because federal judges serve for life, every vacancy filled now is one that will not be available to a future president.
A Supreme Court vacancy during this period could raise the stakes considerably. Republicans could attempt an expedited confirmation before the incoming Senate takes office.
The Dynamic Changes in January
Once Democrats take control, President Trump will retain the power to nominate judges, but Senate Democrats will control the confirmation process.
The practical consequences are likely to differ depending on the court. District court nominees may still offer room for compromise, particularly when home-state senators support the nominee. Court of appeals nominees are likely to face greater scrutiny because those courts frequently have the final word on important questions of federal law and regulation.
If no compromise can be reached on individual nominations, the judicial seat could remain open until after the 2028 presidential election.
For the housing industry and other regulated sectors, the consequences can be significant. Federal appellate courts routinely decide disputes involving:
- Agency authority,
- Environmental regulation,
- Housing,
- Statutory interpretation,
- Preemption and
- Constitutional limits on government regulation.
The judges appointed today can therefore influence regulatory policy long after the administration that appointed them has left office.
An opening on the Supreme Court, however, would kick off a public and potentially nasty political battle as the nominee would be put forward by President Trump and the Republicans would control just 44 votes for confirmation.
State Supreme Courts Mostly Held Their Ground
The elections also included a number of important state supreme court contests, although that overall story was more continuity than realignment.
Twenty-three states voted on supreme court seats last week, in addition to eight states that held judicial elections earlier in the year. The elections included both competitive races and retention elections.
No state supreme court majority flipped outright in 2026, but Democrats and Democratic-backed candidates defended three contested seats in Michigan and North Carolina and gained five seats in Ohio and Texas. Democrats had also made gains on the Wisconsin Supreme Court earlier in the year.
Montana was particularly significant because ideological control of the court was potentially at stake. The more liberal candidate prevailed by roughly 20 percentage points, preserving the court's existing alignment. Republican-backed candidates had greater success earlier in the year in Arkansas and Georgia.
State court elections should not be overlooked. State supreme courts increasingly resolve consequential disputes involving:
- Land use,
- Property rights,
- Environmental regulation,
- Administrative authority,
- Election law and
- State constitutional protections.
Cases raising federal questions can also become vehicles for eventual Supreme Court review.
The Bottom Line
In the short term, Republicans have an incentive to move pending judicial nominees before control of the Senate changes hands. Once the new Congress convenes, however, President Trump’s ability to secure confirmation of federal judges could become substantially more constrained.
And if a Supreme Court vacancy arises, those stakes become much higher. The election did not alter the court’s 6-3 majority. But by changing control of the institution responsible for confirming the next justice, it could ultimately have a significant impact on the Supreme Court’s long-term direction.
For more information on the impact of the 2026 midterms, NAHB members and HBA staff can watch a replay of the recent webinar, "What the Midterm Elections Mean for Housing."