‘Statutory Employer’ Immunity in Jeopardy in Pennsylvania

Labor
Published
Contact: NAHB Office of Legal Advocacy and Compliance
[email protected]
(800) 368-5242 x8359

Pennsylvania's general contractor classification protections are under scrutiny as a case involving a construction company is working its way through the courts. NAHB and the Pennsylvania Builders Association are engaged in the case.

Under Pennsylvania's Worker's Compensation Act Section 302(b), if subcontractors do not pay an injured worker’s compensation claim, the general contractor must then pay those benefits to the subcontractor-employee, thus creating a tier of secondary liability where the general contractor becomes a surety of worker compensation or “statutory employer” of the injured worker.

Being named a “statutory employer” exempts the general contractor from all actions brought by the subcontractor-employee.

In Yoder v. McCarthy Construction, Inc., a jury ordered McCarthy Construction, a general contractor, to pay $5.6 million to the plaintiff for injuries that occurred from a fall on a job site.

On appeal, the Pennsylvania Superior Court reversed and remanded Yoder's award, finding that McCarthy Construction was not liable for a worker’s compensation payout under the “statutory employer” requirement.

Pennsylvania’s Supreme Court has now taken the Yoder case for review and is expected to hear oral arguments early next year.

NAHB has joined the Pennsylvania Builders Association to file an amicus brief in the case. The brief argues that if “statutory employer” protections are removed, general contractors and subcontractors could face significant cost increases at every construction project in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. NAHB will closely monitor the case and similar issues in other jurisdictions.

Subscribe to NAHBNow

Log in or create account to subscribe to notifications of new posts.

Log in to subscribe

Latest from NAHBNow

Housing Affordability

Oct 21, 2025

The Fight for Housing Affordability: NAHB Spotlights Key Hurdles

NAHB CEO Jim Tobin recently appeared on the Builder Straight Talk podcast to highlight the housing affordability hurdles builders face in the current market, and how the Federation is working at the local, state and national levels to address them.

Sponsored Content

Oct 21, 2025

Why Builders Overpay for Land and How to Protect Your Margins

Land is the single largest cost driver in any home building project. But even experienced acquisition teams sometimes overpay. This is often the result of a lack of context and outdated data.

View all

Latest Economic News

Economics

Oct 20, 2025

Non-Conventional Financing for New Home Sales Loses Ground in 2024

Nationwide, the share of non-conventional financing for new home sales accounted for 31% of the market per NAHB analysis of the 2024 Census Bureau Survey of Construction (SOC) data. This is 1.7 percentage point lower than the 2023 share of 32.4%. As in previous years, conventional financing dominated the market at 69.3% of sales, higher than the 2023 share of 67.6%.

Economics

Oct 17, 2025

Better Growth, Larger Deficits: CBO Fiscal Outlook

The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) is a key nonpartisan score keeper that measures the effects of policy changes by the Federal Government. With several policy changes since January of this year, including the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), stricter immigration, and higher tariffs, the CBO updated its economic projections through 2028.

Economics

Oct 16, 2025

Amid Market Challenges, Builder Expectations Rise in October

Even as builders continue to grapple with market and macroeconomic uncertainty, sentiment levels posted a solid gain in October as future sales expectations surpassed the 50-point breakeven mark for the first time since last January.