NAHB Urges SCOTUS to Restrain Federal Agencies’ Power to Interpret Regulations
NAHB is continuing its ongoing battle to rein in excessive regulations and overzealous federal regulators. Most recently on the legal front, NAHB has filed a friend-of-the-court brief in an upcoming Supreme Court case that seeks to overturn a previous Supreme Court decision made decades ago that gives the government an unfair advantage when someone challenges a regulation in court.
In 1984, the Supreme Court issued an opinion in Chevron U.S.A., Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc. That opinion created the “Chevron Doctrine,” which requires courts to abide by a statute if it is “clear,” but also requires courts to defer to a federal agency’s interpretation of an unclear statute if the interpretation is “reasonable,” even if it is not the best interpretation. In other words, Chevron gives federal agencies wide latitude to interpret the scope of regulations.
The Supreme Court will hear oral arguments next term in Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, where the court has been asked to overturn the Chevron ruling. The Loper case involves a group of commercial fishermen who challenged a National Marine Fisheries Service regulation that requires the fishing industry to pay for the costs of observers who monitor compliance with fishery management plans.
Relying on Chevron, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit rejected the companies’ challenge to the rule. The court explained that federal fishery law is clear that the government can require fishing boats to carry observers. However, the statute is silent on who must pay for the observers. The court deferred to NMFS’s interpretation of the law that required the fishermen to pay for the observers because it was “reasonable.”
The Supreme Court agreed to hear the fishermen’s challenge in May, and NAHB filed an amicus brief in the case calling for Chevron to be overturned.
Over the past 40 years, numerous problems have been uncovered due to Chevron.
First, it clearly is biased toward federal agencies by granting them broad leeway to interpret and implement regulations.
Second, Chevron puts too much power in the hands of the unelected agencies. As part of the executive branch, the federal agencies must enforce the laws. However, because Congress also delegates its authority to write the regulations, the agencies both create and enforce many laws. Chevron adds to that problem by putting a “thumb on the scale” in court. Thus, the power of the legislature, executive and judicial branches are merged in the hands of unelected bureaucrats.
Finally, Chevron gives Congress an incentive to write ambiguous laws. Lawmakers want to get statutes passed. Chevron, however, allows Congress to forgo doing the difficult work of drafting clear laws by letting it pass the work off to the agencies. The agencies can then continuously change the law – and the intent of Congress – by implementing their own interpretation as long as they are “reasonable.”
Latest from NAHBNow
Sep 09, 2025
Why Land Deals Fall Apart — and How to Protect Your PipelineTeams that can see competitor strategies earlier, understand where capital is flowing, and anticipate growth corridors will be better positioned to protect margins and capture opportunity. Achieving that higher standard means moving beyond lagging signals and fragmented records to complete land intelligence. This is exactly what the Acres Home Builder Index is built to provide.
Sep 08, 2025
Industry to Celebrate Professional Women in Building Week Sept. 15-19Join NAHB for a week of inspiring events and learning opportunities that showcase the achievements of women the industry. PWB Week will also highlight our efforts to promote, train, advance and recruit more women into the field.
Latest Economic News
Sep 09, 2025
Share of New Homes with Patios Edges Down for First Time in Fifteen YearsFor the first time in 15 years, the share of new homes with patios finally declined in 2024, according to NAHB tabulation of data from the Survey of Construction (conducted by the U.S. Census Bureau with partial funding from the Department of Housing and Urban Development).
Sep 09, 2025
Who Are NAHB Remodelers?Twenty-one percent of NAHB builder members listed residential remodeling as their primary business activity, according to the 2024 Member Census. These remodelers tend to be relatively small companies, with a median of five employees, $1.7 million in median revenue, and 15 remodeling jobs completed over $10,000.
Sep 08, 2025
Purchase Activity Slips Despite Lower Mortgage RatesMortgage application activity increased again in August, supported by lower interest rates. The Mortgage Bankers Association’s (MBA) Market Composite Index, a measure of total mortgage application volume, rose 5.0% from July on a seasonally adjusted basis and was 18.3% higher than a year ago.