SCOTUS Takes on WOTUS

Environment
Published

At the urging of NAHB and other business groups, the U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to hear a challenge to the Clean Water Act that would clarify an earlier ruling from the nation’s highest court issued in 2006.

The Supreme Court indicated it will hear the case perhaps when its new term begins in October. NAHB and other stakeholders are hoping the decision will provide the regulatory certainty that landowners, states and local governments need so they know where to avoid impacts to wetlands, streams and ponds.

In the 2006 case Rapanos vs. U.S., the Supreme Court issued a split 4-1-4 decision regarding the definition of “waters of the United States.” (WOTUS) that led to two different tests to determine jurisdictional waters. Then-Justice Anthony Kennedy proposed a definition which rejected the Environmental Protection Agency and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’ ability to automatically assert jurisdiction over any activity impacting an isolated wetland or water that lacked a “significant nexus” to a traditional navigable water.

A narrower definition proposed by then-Justice Anthony Scalia said that a wetland must have “continuous surface connection” to regulated waters, meaning it must be connected to a river, lake or other waterway.

The Supreme Court agreed to hear a case brought by Idaho couple Chantell and Mike Sackett, who previously won an earlier case in the high court in 2012 when it ruled the Sacketts could challenge the EPA in federal court before the agency took final enforcement action.

For years, the Sacketts have been battling the EPA over whether there are wetlands on their property that would force the couple to apply for a federal permit under the Clean Water Act. Part of this stems from the uncertainty over whether to follow the Scalia or Kennedy model in determining the limits of federal jurisdiction over isolated non-navigable wetlands under the Clean Water Act.

The Biden administration is currently rewriting the WOTUS definition to expand federal jurisdiction over non-navigable, isolated, or even ephemeral features based upon whether or not EPA or the Corps claimed those features met Justice Kennedy’s “significant nexus” test.

NAHB has been critical of the Biden administration’s proposed WOTUS rule, as well as its decision to rescind the Trump administration’s WOTUS rule that relies upon Justice Scalia’s “continuous surface connection” test rather than “significant nexus” to establish Clean Water Act jurisdiction over only those wetlands and tributaries that maintained a direct surface water connection to another traditional navigable water.

Finally, NAHB has also been concerned over the level of transparency by the Corps and EPA regarding the likely economic impact resulting from the proposed WOTUS definition upon small businesses like NAHB’s membership, as well as the limited opportunities for public engagement during the rulemaking process.

NAHB is urging Congress to use its oversight authority to intervene and direct EPA and the Corps to extend the public comment period beyond the current Feb. 7 deadline as well as comply with the Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act by convening a panel to solicit the input of small businesses, including NAHB members, before finalizing a new WOTUS regulatory definition under the Clean Water Act.

For more information, contact Tom Ward or Michael Mittelholzer.

Subscribe to NAHBNow

Log in or create account to subscribe to notifications of new posts.

Log in to subscribe

Latest from NAHBNow

IBS

Aug 12, 2025

2026 Show Home Takes Shape in Orlando

Construction is moving full-speed ahead on The New American Home 2026. Located in Winter Park, Fla., this ambitious project is implementing cutting-edge design while sticking to an aggressive timeline — and the build team has no intention of slowing down.

IBS

Aug 11, 2025

3 Reasons to Attend the 2026 International Builders’ Show

The NAHB International Builders’ Show® (IBS) is the premier event for the residential construction industry, bringing together tens of thousands of industry professionals and 1,700+ top manufacturers and suppliers every year.

View all

Latest Economic News

Economics

Aug 11, 2025

Market Share for Modular and Other Non-Site Built Housing in 2024

The total market share of non-site built single-family homes (modular and panelized) was just 3% of single-family homes in 2024, according to completion data from the Census Bureau Survey of Construction data and NAHB analysis.

Economics

Aug 08, 2025

Foundation Types in 2024: Slabs Continue to Rise, Crawl Spaces Decline

In 2024, 73% of new single-family homes started were built on slab foundations, according to NAHB analysis of the U.S. Census Bureau’s Survey of Construction (SOC).

Economics

Aug 08, 2025

Weaker Demand for Residential Mortgages in Second Quarter

In the second quarter of 2025, overall demand for residential mortgages was weaker, while lending standards for most types of residential mortgages were essentially unchanged, according to the recent release of the Senior Loan Officer Opinion Survey (SLOOS).