U.S. Supreme Court Embraces Property Owner’s Right to Exclude
The U.S. Supreme Court today issued a Fifth Amendment “takings” decision that is a win for property owners. The Fifth Amendment provides that the government may not take private property unless it pays the owner just compensation.
In this case, a California regulation granted labor organizers a right to access a farmer’s property to solicit support for unionization. The regulation allowed the organizers access for up to three hours a day, 120 days per year. The farmer argued that allowing the organizers on their property was an unconstitutional “physical taking” of their property.
The majority of the Supreme Court agreed. Chief Justice John Roberts, joined by five other justices, explained that the a “central importance” of property ownership is the “right to exclude” others.
The lower court and the dissent took the view that the regulation did not cause a ”physical taking“ because it did not allow a permanent and continuous invasion (24 hours a day, 365 days per year) of the farmer’s property.
The Supreme Court majority tore apart this argument by explaining that it does not matter if the government only invades a person’s property for 364 days, instead of 365 days; the fact that the invasion is from time to time does not make it any less physical.
In its conclusion, the Supreme Court did recognize that not all government invasions of private property require compensation. It provided examples of making an arrest, requiring a landowner to provide access in exchange for a permit, or abating a nuisance on private property. None of these amount to a taking of private property.
Latest from NAHBNow
Jun 23, 2025
How Taylor Swift's Music is Influencing an NAHB PWB CouncilTaylor Swift's music is resonating with members of an NAHB Professional Women in Building (PWB) Council thanks to a new leadership seminar diving in the deeper meanings of her lyrics.
Jun 20, 2025
NAHB Announces Latest Round of Legal Funding for HBA LawsuitsAt the 2025 Spring Leadership Meeting, the Legal Action Committee reviewed several funding requests that reflect the growing complexity and urgency of legal threats facing the home building industry and awarded grants in three cases.
Latest Economic News
Jun 23, 2025
Existing Home Sales Edge Higher in MayExisting home sales rose 0.8% in May but remained near historical lows, according to the National Association of Realtors (NAR). Despite the modest increase, this marks the slowest pace for May since 2009. The sluggish sales suggest higher mortgage rates and elevated home prices continue to sideline buyers even with improved inventory conditions.
Jun 20, 2025
Single-family Construction Loan Volume GrowsCredit conditions for builders and developers eased in the first quarter of 2025 as the level of outstanding 1-4 family residential construction loans rose for the first time in two years, according to data released by FDIC.
Jun 18, 2025
The Fed Pause ContinuesReflecting most forecasters’ expectations for the June FOMC meeting, the Federal Reserve continued its post-2024 pause for federal funds rate cuts, retaining a target rate of 4.5% to 4.25%.