Supreme Court Ruling Reaffirms Power of Federal Regulators

Codes and Standards
Published

The Supreme Court today narrowly decided to uphold, with significant limits, a doctrine that has plagued the regulated community for years. The case, Kisor v. Wilkie, addressed the issue of whether courts should defer to an agency’s interpretation of its own regulations, known also as Auer deference.  

NAHB supported the petitioner with amicus briefs on behalf of an industry coalition organized by the association. NAHB has long been concerned with this type of judicial deference because it can create incentives for agencies to avoid formal rulemaking processes, or create vague regulations that they can interpret and re-interpret at a later date. Either tactic prevents the regulated community from participating in the development of the rules that govern their activities.

Auer deference has harmed NAHB’s interest in a number of cases, including a Clean Water Act case where the court relied on Auer to affirm the finding of a violation against property owners who had constructed a ditch to build a residential subdivision.

In a fractured opinion written by Justice Elena Kagan, the Supreme Court declined to overrule its precedent establishing this deference doctrine, and instead identified a series of factors that courts should use when determining whether Auer deference is appropriate. The court stressed that, under this new formulation, the situations where Auer will be applied will be far fewer than is currently the case.

It remains to be seen whether the limitations recommended by the court will address the many problems that NAHB and others in the regulated community have raised.

NAHB will vigilantly monitor the application of this re-imagined Auer deference in the lower courts, and engage in opportunities to ensure that the newly-outlined limitations are broadly applied.

Subscribe to NAHBNow

Log in or create account to subscribe to notifications of new posts.

Log in to subscribe

Latest from NAHBNow

Advocacy

Oct 02, 2025

Vermont Executive Order Addresses Builders' Top Priorities

Two Vermont Builders and Remodelers Association members stood with Gov. Phil Scott as he signed an executive order to address regulatory barriers, permitting challenges and energy code standards in the state.

Legal

Oct 01, 2025

Get National Resources for Local Issues with NAHB's Legal Action Fund

NAHB’s Legal Action Fund provides support for members facing critical legal challenges that directly impede their ability to develop land and build homes. The current deadline to apply for support is October 28.

View all

Latest Economic News

Economics

Oct 01, 2025

Consumer Confidence Drops on Job Concerns

Consumer confidence fell to a five-month low as consumers remain concerned about reignited inflation and a weakening labor market amid economic uncertainty. The labor market differential, which measures the gap between consumers viewing job as plentiful and hard-to-get, has narrowed for nine straight month and is now at lowest level since March 2021.

Economics

Sep 30, 2025

Construction Labor Market Softens

The count of open, unfilled positions in the construction industry decreased in August, per the Bureau of Labor Statistics Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS). The decline occurred as home building weakened in 2025.

Economics

Sep 29, 2025

Characteristics of Homes Built in Age-Restricted Communities

In 2024, approximately 43,000 homes were built in age-restricted communities, representing just over 3% of all housing starts. According to the Census Bureau’s Survey of Construction, roughly three-quarters of these homes (32,000) were single-family units.